- 1. What Is Proof of Reserves?
- 2. Why Is Proof of Reserves Important?
- 3. How Does a Proof of Reserves Audit Work for Cryptocurrencies?
- 4. What Are the Best Methods to Verify a Crypto Exchange's Reserves?
- 5. How to Verify Your Own Balance in the Merkle Tree
- 6. Reserve Ratios: Reading Assets Against Liabilities
- 7. Which Exchanges Publish Proof of Reserves? Latest Reports
- 8. What Proof of Reserves Does Not Prove
- 9. Attestations, Audits and Zero-Knowledge Proofs
- 10. Red Flags in a Proof-of-Reserves Report
- 11. How We Built This Guide
- 12. Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answer: To check an exchange’s proof of reserves, open its proof-of-reserves page, confirm the snapshot date, read the reserve ratio for every coin you hold, check that your own balance is in the Merkle tree and see who reviewed the report. Blockchainreporter’s check on November 21, 2026 found recent reports at OKX, Binance, Bybit, KuCoin, Gate and Kraken, while Crypto.com’s only report dates from December 2022 and Coinbase has none for exchange customer balances.
Proof of reserves (PoR) is an exchange’s public evidence that it holds enough crypto to cover what customers have on deposit. This guide explains how the reports work, how to verify your own balance, what the numbers do not show and which red flags to watch for. For a ranking of exchanges by how open their reports are, see our ranking of exchanges with proof of reserves.
What Is Proof of Reserves?
A proof of reserves compares two numbers at one moment. The first is the crypto in wallets the exchange controls. The second is the balance it owes its customers in the same coin. If the first is equal to or larger than the second, the customer balances the report covers were backed one to one at that moment. Our glossary entry on proof of reserves has the short definition.
Exchange failures made the idea popular. Mt. Gox, once the largest Bitcoin exchange, collapsed in 2014 after hackers stole at least 647,000 BTC from it over about three years, according to the US Justice Department. Our history of Mt. Gox tells that story in full.
FTX failed in 2022. The Justice Department later said its founder had stolen over $8 billion of customers’ money. OKX’s own page dates its first Merkle-tree verification method to November 22, 2022, and most large exchanges began publishing reports around that time.
Why Is Proof of Reserves Important?
Proof of reserves matters because customers cannot see inside an exchange’s books. When you deposit coins, the exchange keeps them in its own wallets and records your balance in its database. A regular report lets anyone check that the coins are still there, instead of taking the exchange’s word for it.
It also helps in a crisis. After attackers took about $6.3 billion from Binance wallets on October 29, 2026 (UTC), Binance published a snapshot taken at 00:00 UTC on November 12. It showed Bitcoin reserves at 100.05%. Our report on Binance reopening withdrawals has the timeline.
Not every exchange uses the same model. Coinbase, a US listed company, publishes no proof of reserves for exchange customer balances. Its reserve page covers only cbBTC, its wrapped bitcoin token, and showed 102,777.38 BTC against 102,766.62 cbBTC on November 21, 2026. For the exchange itself, Coinbase files financial statements with the US Securities and Exchange Commission, and its annual accounts are audited.
How Does a Proof of Reserves Audit Work for Cryptocurrencies?
Despite the name, most of these reports are not audits. The US Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) said in March 2023 that such engagements “are not audits.” Most reports follow the same four steps:
- Prove wallet ownership. The exchange shows it controls the addresses it lists. OKX publishes its addresses with a signed message that reads “I am an OKX address.” Bybit uses a “Send to Self” method: each listed address sends a set amount back to itself at a set time, or to another listed address on chains such as TRON that do not allow self-transfers.
- Snapshot customer balances. The exchange records every customer’s net balance at a fixed moment, for example 00:00 UTC on November 12, 2026, in Binance’s latest report.
- Build a Merkle tree. Each account’s hashed ID and balances become a leaf in a Merkle tree. Leaves are hashed in pairs until one Merkle root is left, and the exchange publishes that root. If any balance changes, the root changes.
- Compare and publish ratios. The exchange divides its wallet holdings by customer balances for each coin. Bybit states the formula plainly: wallet assets divided by user assets.
Some exchanges add a zero-knowledge proof. OKX uses a zk-STARK to prove three rules: the total equals the sum of all accounts, no account has a negative balance and every account is included. Binance and Gate use zk-SNARKs. These proofs check the liability side without showing anyone’s account.
What Are the Best Methods to Verify a Crypto Exchange’s Reserves?
Use this checklist each time an exchange publishes a new report:
- Check the date. A snapshot shows one moment. Kraken’s latest is from September 30, 2026, and Crypto.com’s only report is from December 7, 2022.
- Read the ratio for each coin you hold. A high total can hide a shortfall in one asset. Look for 100% or more on your coins, not just on the total.
- Find your Merkle leaf. Log in and copy your record ID or Merkle leaf from the proof-of-reserves page.
- Run the checker. Use the exchange’s tool or its open-source verifier to confirm your leaf sits under the published root.
- Look up the wallets. Compare the published addresses with a block explorer.
- See who reviewed it. A named outside firm adds a layer of checking. Read what that firm actually looked at.
- Keep a note. Write down the date, the ratios and your result, so you can compare the next report.
How to Verify Your Own Balance in the Merkle Tree
The steps differ by exchange. These are the paths each exchange gives on its own proof-of-reserves page, as read on November 21, 2026:
- Binance. Log in and open Wallet, then Verification. The page shows your Merkle leaf and record ID, the date, the assets covered and your balances at that moment.
- OKX. Open your PoR reports, click Details and copy your data into a file whose name ends in “_inclusion_proof.json.” Run OKX’s open-source zk-STARK Validator in the same folder. A pass reads “Inclusion constraint validation passed.”
- Kraken. In Kraken Pro, open the Account icon, then Proof of Reserves. Pick the review date and click Verify yourself. You can check with the accountant’s tool, using the first 16 characters of your Merkle leaf ID, or with Kraken’s own tools.
- Bybit. On the proof-of-reserves page, open “View my audit data” and copy your proof into a file named myProof.json. Run it through the open-source validator in Bybit’s merkle-proof repository on GitHub, which returns a true or false result.
- Gate. Download Gate’s verification program, then the Merkle tree and user config files for the batch from your audit page. Run the program in the same folder. A pass shows “All proofs verify passed!!!”
- Crypto.com. Copy your Merkle leaf in the app and paste it on the auditor’s page. This only covers the December 7, 2022 snapshot.
A passed check proves one thing: your balance was counted in that snapshot. It says nothing about the exchange’s other debts.
Reserve Ratios: Reading Assets Against Liabilities
The reserve ratio is the exchange’s wallet balance for one coin divided by what customers hold in that coin. Binance’s November 12 snapshot listed 688,283.654 BTC in reserves against 687,912.027 BTC in net customer balances. That works out to 100.05%, a cushion of about 372 BTC.
Three details change how much a ratio tells you:
- Third-party custody. Part of a reserve may sit with outside custodians, not in wallets you can see. Binance counted 10,539.645 BTC of its Bitcoin reserve this way and OKX 7,163 BTC. OKX tells users to contact those custodians to verify such balances.
- Net balances move. Bybit says the net value of accounts can shift with open profit and loss, leverage, borrowing and investment products. A ratio measures one moment only.
- The exchange’s own token. Reports also cover tokens the exchange issues, such as BNB at Binance (100.39%) and OKB at OKX (100%). When such a token counts toward a reserve total in dollars, that part of the total moves with the token’s price.
A ratio above 100% is not a measure of the exchange’s own money. Binance’s page says the excess assets in its reserve addresses do not show the overall amount of its own assets.
Which Exchanges Publish Proof of Reserves? Latest Reports
Blockchainreporter’s check of each exchange’s latest proof-of-reserves report on November 21, 2026:
| Exchange | Latest snapshot | BTC | ETH | USDT | Method | Outside check |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OKX | Nov 1, 2026 (UTC+8), 49th report | 108% | 101% | 106% | Merkle tree + zk-STARK | None named |
| Binance | Nov 12, 2026, 00:00 UTC | 100.05% | 100.02% | 104.34% | Merkle tree + zk-SNARK | None named |
| Bybit | Oct 27, 2026, 06:00 UTC, report #41 | 102% | 101% | 112% | Merkle tree | Hacken |
| KuCoin | Oct 31, 2026 (UTC+8) | 112% | 115% | 110% | Merkle tree | Independent third party, not named |
| Gate | Oct 18, 2026, batch #104 | 121.60% | 123.78% | 111.68% | Merkle tree + zk-SNARK | None for figures; Hacken code audit, Jan 3, 2024 |
| Kraken | Sept 30, 2026 | 103.2% | 100.7% | 105% or more | Merkle tree | Independent accountant, not named |
| Bitget* | Nov 12, 2026 (UTC+8) | 127% | 103% | 114% | Merkle tree | None named |
| Crypto.com | Dec 7, 2022 | Not shown as text | Not shown as text | Not shown as text | Merkle tree | Mazars (ISRS 4400) |
| Coinbase | None for exchange customer balances; cbBTC reserve page only | None | None | None | Audited financial statements | Public-company auditor |
*Bitget’s page showed no reserve data on November 21, 2026, so its figures are from its November 12 snapshot as we last read it on November 14. All other figures are the exchanges’ own, read on their proof-of-reserves pages on November 21, 2026.
Each ratio is the exchange’s wallet holdings divided by customer balances in that coin. Our proof-of-reserves ranking scores the same exchanges on how often they report, how users can check and who reviews the figures. Our list of the best crypto exchanges adds fees, licences and security history.
What Proof of Reserves Does Not Prove
A proof of reserves compares assets with customer balances at one moment. It is not a full picture of an exchange’s finances. Kraken lists the limits on its own page:
- It cannot prove that the exchange alone holds the private keys. An attacker could hold a copy.
- It cannot find hidden encumbrances, or show that coins were not borrowed to pass the review.
- It cannot account for keys lost or funds stolen after the review date.
- It only works if the accountant is competent and independent.
The PCAOB added in March 2023 that such reports likely do not address an exchange’s liabilities and give no assurance on internal controls. Debts outside customer balances, such as loans the exchange has taken or legal claims against it, do not appear in a Merkle tree. Neither does anything that happens after the snapshot.
Attestations, Audits and Zero-Knowledge Proofs
Who checked a report matters as much as its ratio. The labels mean different things:
- Self-published reports. OKX, Binance and Bitget publish their own figures and tools and name no outside firm for the numbers.
- Security firm reviews. Bybit lists the blockchain security firm Hacken as the audit firm on each 2026 report. Gate lists a January 3, 2024 Hacken security audit of its proof-of-reserves code, which checked the system rather than each batch’s figures.
- Accountant procedures. Kraken says an independent third-party accountant performs its review. Crypto.com’s December 2022 report was a verification by Mazars under ISRS 4400, the international standard for agreed-upon procedures. Under that standard, readers draw their own conclusions from the work performed.
- Financial statement audits. A full audit covers the whole balance sheet, including liabilities. Coinbase relies on audited financial statements filed with the SEC.
- Zero-knowledge proofs. They let anyone check, without seeing private account data, that the liability total equals the sum of the accounts in the tree and that none is negative. They cannot show that every customer account was included or that the reserves exist.
Red Flags in a Proof-of-Reserves Report
Watch for these signs when you read a report:
- An old snapshot. A report several months old says little about today. Crypto.com’s page still points to December 2022.
- Only a total ratio. A total above 100% can hide a coin below 100%.
- No way to check your own balance. Without a Merkle leaf or a verifier, you have to trust the figures.
- An unnamed reviewer. “An independent third party” with no name cannot be looked up. KuCoin’s page uses this wording, and Kraken’s page does not name its accountant either.
- Large off-chain portions. Coins at outside custodians cannot be seen on a block explorer.
- Reserves in the exchange’s own token. That part of the reserve rises and falls with confidence in the exchange.
This guide is for education only and is not investment advice.
How We Built This Guide
We want readers to see where every number comes from. Here is our method:
- Exchange data. We read each exchange’s own proof-of-reserves page on November 21, 2026, except Bitget’s, which showed no data that day, so its figures are from November 14. Ratios and dates are the exchanges’ figures.
- Rules and standards. We used the PCAOB investor advisory of March 8, 2023, IFAC material on ISRS 4400 and US Justice Department releases.
- No ranking here. This guide explains the method. Our ranking page scores the exchanges, and we update it when new reports appear.
- Dates. Every figure carries its snapshot date, because reserves change after each snapshot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is proof of reserves the same as an audit?
No. A proof of reserves shows assets against customer balances at one moment. A financial statement audit covers the year-end balance sheet, including other debts, and the year’s results. The US Public Company Accounting Oversight Board said in March 2023 that proof-of-reserves engagements are not audits and do not provide meaningful assurance. Most exchanges publish their own reports, sometimes with a review by an outside firm.
How often do exchanges publish proof of reserves?
OKX and Bitget say they publish every month, and Bybit’s recent reports came about a month apart. On November 21, 2026, OKX’s latest report was dated November 1, Binance’s November 12, KuCoin’s October 31, Bybit’s October 27 and Gate’s October 18. Kraken publishes quarterly, most recently for September 30. Crypto.com has not updated its December 2022 report.
Does Coinbase have proof of reserves?
Coinbase publishes no proof of reserves for exchange customer balances. Its reserve page covers only cbBTC, its wrapped bitcoin token. As a US listed company, Coinbase files financial statements with the Securities and Exchange Commission, and its annual accounts are audited. These cover the whole company, including its liabilities, but customers cannot check their own balance against them the way a Merkle tree allows.
Can proof of reserves prevent an exchange collapse?
Not on its own. A report can reveal a shortfall in customer assets on its snapshot date, which raises pressure on the exchange to fix it. It cannot show hidden debts, borrowed coins or problems that begin after the snapshot. Kraken’s own page lists these limits. The PCAOB warned in March 2023 that customers should exercise extreme caution when relying on such reports.
What reserve ratio should a report show?
A coin’s ratio of 100% or more means the exchange held at least as many of that coin as its customers at the snapshot time. In the latest reports, Bitcoin ratios ran from 100.05% at Binance to 127% at Bitget, whose November 12 figures we read on November 14. A total ratio can hide a weak coin, so the ratio for each coin you hold tells you more.
Exchange sources, all read on November 21, 2026: OKX proof of reserves; Binance proof of reserves; Bybit’s 41st proof-of-reserves release (November 3, 2026) and Hacken’s report on the October 27 snapshot; KuCoin proof of reserves; Gate proof of reserves; Kraken proof of reserves; Crypto.com proof of reserves; Bitget proof of reserves, which showed no data that day; Coinbase cbBTC proof of reserves.
Rules and standards: PCAOB investor advisory on proof of reserve reports (March 8, 2023); IFAC on the revised agreed-upon procedures standard; US Justice Department, Southern District of New York, on the FTX sentence (March 28, 2024); US Justice Department on the Mt. Gox thefts (June 9, 2023); Binance’s update on its October 2026 security incident.
About the author
Tokoni Uti is a Lagos-based writer with several years of experience. Her work has appeared in the Huffington Post, the Los Angeles Free Press and the San Diego Free press among others. She is a graduate of Bowen University.